Planning – Application Comments

Help with this page (opens in a new window)

2025/1057/FUL | Retrospective application for 8 new roof lights. | Meadow Croft Barn Rookery Lane Stretton Rutland LE15 7RA Decision: Approve
  • Print summary icon
Received
Tue 26 Aug 2025
Validated
Wed 27 Aug 2025
Consultation
Thu 25 Sep 2025
Recommendation and/or Committee
Decided
Wed 22 Oct 2025
  • Total Consulted: 4
  • Comments Received: 1
  • Objections: 1
  • Supporting: 0
  • View all comments icon

Search Filters

Collapse All|Expand All

Mr Kevin Hawkes 1 Rectory Farm Cottage Rookery Lane Stretton Rutland LE15 7RA (Objects)

Comment submitted date: Mon 15 Sep 2025

PLEASE ALSO REFERENCE IMAGES SENT BY EMAIL TO PLANNING SUPPORT.

Objection: 2025/1057/FUL - Meadow Croft Barn, Rookery Lane, Stretton
From: Mr & Mrs KC Hawkes - 1 Rectory Farm Cottage, Rookery Lane, Stretton, Oakham, LE15 7RA
Date: 14th September 2025
Dear Mr Mitson,
We object to the retrospective application 2025/1057/FUL. The works are not like-for-like and they cause harm to the character and appearance of the Stretton Conservation Area and to the setting of four nearby Grade II listed buildings, three of which abut the applicants property.
Not like-for-like: size, position and operation have all changed
The applicant's Design and Access Statement (DAS) says the eight new Velux "FK06" conservation roof windows were "fitted within the same roof cut outs" and are therefore "like for like," with all replacements "660 mm by 1180 mm" and mid-pivot opening.
Our photos show the openings were enlarged by around 200 mm in length and every new window has been raised by approximately one pantile towards the ridge to accommodate the larger size. The operation has changed from side opening to mid-pivot, which the DAS itself acknowledges was not the original arrangement.
The flashings are materially larger than before, increasing visual mass and reflectivity across the roof planes. This is not a like-for-like replacement. It is a material alteration that fails the design tests in CS19 and SP15 on scale, detailing and relationship to context.
Public visibility and heritage setting
The DAS downplays visibility by suggesting only "limited views" from Rookery Lane.
In reality, the entire west-facing elevation is visible from Rookery Lane, and our photo shows the altered roof with the Grade II listed village church in the same view. The eight enlarged and higher-set openings, together with bigger flashings, change the established rhythm of modest apertures typical of converted barns here. That affects the character and appearance of the conservation area and the setting of the surrounding listed buildings, engaging SP20 and CS22, which require preservation or enhancement and protection of setting, and a proportionate understanding of significance.
Public views matter in principle. The NPPF asks decision makers to protect and enhance public rights of way and access, which makes visibility from the highway and the public footpath material to the assessment. GOV.UK Assets We have provided a plan of the applicant's land confirming a public footpath crosses it, from which the south elevation windows are visible.

Amenity: new overlooking and loss of privacy
Before the change there were no direct inward views into our principal rooms. The new windows are larger, set higher and pivot open differently, which increases the perception of overlooking. SP15 requires protection of neighbouring amenity in terms of overlooking and loss of privacy; CS19 expects development to avoid unacceptable effects through visual intrusion and overlooking. The proposal conflicts with those requirements.
Energy-efficiency claims do not outweigh harm
We support sensitive retrofit. Proposed Policy CC7 expects the "sensitive retrofitting" of energy efficiency measures in historic buildings and conservation areas whilst safeguarding special characteristics.
Enlarging and raising openings, changing operation and using heavier flashings are not the only route to improved performance, and no alternatives analysis has been provided. On CC7's own terms the approach is not justified. The NPPF gives significant weight to energy-efficiency improvements to existing buildings, but it is explicit that where proposals affect conservation areas or the setting of listed buildings, the heritage policies still apply and any harm needs clear and convincing justification. GOV.UK Assets+1
For context, the DAS notes both that permitted development rights were removed on conversion and that the Stretton Conservation Area has an Article 4 Direction affecting elevations next to main roads. Either way, national and local heritage policies are engaged and carry great weight.
Accuracy of the submission
The application narrative states like-for-like within the "same roof cut outs."
Our enlarged photos and measurements demonstrate the cut-outs have been enlarged and raised. The DAS further minimises visibility from Rookery Lane, which is contradicted by on-street views including the listed church in the same frame. We have also provided a plan of the applicant's land, which allows the authority to assess public views and setting more accurately than the submitted location plan suggests. Government guidance expects a red line around the application land and a blue line around any other land in the applicant's ownership close to or adjoining the site on the location plan. If the latter is missing, that affects proper assessment and notification. GOV.UK
We also record that the works started on 22 July and continued for seven days, not from 25 to 28 July as stated. The longer programme is consistent with structural alterations needed to create larger openings.
National policy
The NPPF confirms that heritage policies govern decisions where conservation areas and the setting of listed buildings are engaged. Great weight must be given to conservation, and any harm needs clear and convincing justification, with any less than substantial harm weighed against public benefits. It also requires good design that reflects local character. Relevant paragraphs include Chapter 12 on design (131-132 and 139) and Chapter 16 on heritage (207-213, 215 and 219). Public rights of way and highway views are material (para 105). Energy efficiency in existing buildings carries significant weight but must still respect heritage policies (para 167). GOV.UK Assets+2GOV.UK Assets+2
Relevant precedent on Rookery Lane
In February 2025, the Planning Inspectorate dismissed an appeal at Jacob's Barn, Rookery Lane, for retrospective replacement windows and doors within the Stretton Conservation Area. The Inspector found that thicker frames and increased reflectivity were harmful and noted the elevations were visible from multiple viewpoints along Rookery Lane. The appeal was dismissed and CS19, CS22, SP15 and SP20 were central to the reasoning. This is a highly relevant, recent decision on the same street. Rutland County Council
Policy conclusion
On the evidence, the works are not a like-for-like replacement. Enlarged and re-sited roof windows, bigger flashings and changed operation across three elevations cause harm to the conservation area and to the setting of four listed buildings. The scheme conflicts with CS19 and CS22 of the Core Strategy, and SP15 and SP20 of the Site Allocations and Policies DPD.
The applicant's reliance on energy-efficiency is addressed by proposed CC7, which supports retrofit only where heritage characteristics are safeguarded. That has not been demonstrated.
We respectfully request refusal.
If the Council is minded to approve, we ask for conditions requiring reinstatement of the original opening dimensions and positions, conservation-grade detailing to match the former profiles, and, at minimum, a proportionate Heritage Impact Assessment that records the original and current apertures and assesses effects on the conservation area and listed settings in line with SP20 and proposed EN12.
Attachments provided
We have submitted enlarged before-and-after photos for comparison, a measured schedule for each of the eight windows noting the one-pantile vertical shift on each elevation, the Rookery Lane viewpoint photo with the listed church in the background, and a plan of the applicant's land. For ease of reference the DAS images also show five windows on the west elevation, two on the south and one on the east.

Sources
- Applicant's Design and Access / Heritage Statement, 2025/1057/FUL.
- Rutland Core Strategy DPD (2011): CS19 Promoting good design; CS22 The historic and cultural environment.
- Rutland Site Allocations & Policies DPD (2014): SP15 Design and amenity; SP20 The historic environment.
- Rutland Reg 19 Local Plan (2024) extracts: CC7 Reducing energy consumption in existing buildings; EN12 Historic and cultural environment.
- National Planning Policy Framework (Dec 2024, amended 7 Feb 2025): Chapter 12 paras 131-132, 139; Chapter 16 paras 207-213, 215, 219; para 105 on public rights of way; para 167 on energy efficiency. GOV.UK Assets+1
- GOV.UK guidance on location plans and showing land within the applicant's ownership with a blue line. GOV.UK
- Planning Inspectorate appeal decision, Jacob's Barn, Rookery Lane, APP/A2470/D/24/3349765, dismissed 24 Feb 2025. Rutland County Council

Yours faithfully,
Mr & Mrs KC Hawkes

Powered by Idox